Don't like the ads? Then create an account! Users with accounts have more options than anonymous users. |
Editing Talk:Recorder
From Triforce Wiki, a The Legend of Zelda wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
![]() |
You are not currently logged in. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits. While you are free to edit without logging in, your IP address will be recorded publicly, along with the time and date, in this page's edit history. Messages sent to your IP can be viewed on your talk page. | |
![]() |
![]() |
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
Should this article include the Flute from ''The Adventure of Link''? The Japanese manuals share the same name, 「<span class="explain" title="ふえ">笛</span>」 (''fue''), but the intro of the first game specifically identifies it as a "Recorder" (katakana: フエ), which is a '''type''' of flute; in ''The Adventure of Link'', its design is decidedly '''not''' a recorder (although the design in the first game is technically off as well since it seems to be missing a hole or two). There is some conflict with the name of the "Flute" from ''A Link to the Past'', which is technically an ocarina, and the one from the CD-i games, which seems to have design features of both NES games. If this article is only covering the version from the first game, I definitely think the article title should really be "Recorder" since it is the in-game name in ''The Legend of Zelda'', ''Hyrule Warriors'' (as "8-Bit Recorder"), and ''Paper Mario: Color Splash''. [[User:LTL|LTL]] ([[User talk:LTL|talk]]) 14:44, 27 January 2020 (UTC) | Should this article include the Flute from ''The Adventure of Link''? The Japanese manuals share the same name, 「<span class="explain" title="ふえ">笛</span>」 (''fue''), but the intro of the first game specifically identifies it as a "Recorder" (katakana: フエ), which is a '''type''' of flute; in ''The Adventure of Link'', its design is decidedly '''not''' a recorder (although the design in the first game is technically off as well since it seems to be missing a hole or two). There is some conflict with the name of the "Flute" from ''A Link to the Past'', which is technically an ocarina, and the one from the CD-i games, which seems to have design features of both NES games. If this article is only covering the version from the first game, I definitely think the article title should really be "Recorder" since it is the in-game name in ''The Legend of Zelda'', ''Hyrule Warriors'' (as "8-Bit Recorder"), and ''Paper Mario: Color Splash''. [[User:LTL|LTL]] ([[User talk:LTL|talk]]) 14:44, 27 January 2020 (UTC) | ||
:When I made this page, I was definitely confused about the flute resembling an ocarina in ''A Link to the Past''. I'd say we go by your word, but I'd also like to see what Doc's thoughts are on this. I bought the PDF of Clyde's Legend of Localization, so I was trying my best to go by what it was saying. As for the Flute from ''Zelda II: The Adventure of Link'', I was hesitant on adding that as they are clearly different subjects, although the article could be written to cover generic recorders from the franchise overall? [[User:Results May Vary|Results May Vary]] ([[User talk:Results May Vary|talk]]) 15:10, 27 January 2020 (UTC) | :When I made this page, I was definitely confused about the flute resembling an ocarina in ''A Link to the Past''. I'd say we go by your word, but I'd also like to see what Doc's thoughts are on this. I bought the PDF of Clyde's Legend of Localization, so I was trying my best to go by what it was saying. As for the Flute from ''Zelda II: The Adventure of Link'', I was hesitant on adding that as they are clearly different subjects, although the article could be written to cover generic recorders from the franchise overall? [[User:Results May Vary|Results May Vary]] ([[User talk:Results May Vary|talk]]) 15:10, 27 January 2020 (UTC) | ||